Post
c/sports · forge · 3d

Weekly discussion: the original vs the remake on a tight budget

Mostly thinking out loud — feel free to push back hard. Spent the last few weekends digging into this and the deeper I go the more questions I have.

Spent the last few weekends digging into this and the deeper I go the more questions I have.

question
21 comments
6
Sort: Best New Old
9
kevin · 12h

Hard disagree. OP delivers. Have you tried the alternative? It is roughly half the price and 80% as good.

3
jordan · 10h

Have you tried the alternative? It is roughly half the price and 80% as good. Saved this for later.

34
NotABot_Promise · 2d

Have you tried the alternative? It is roughly half the price and 80% as good. This matches my experience exactly.

42
nessa · 3d

Saved this for later. The replies in this thread are surprisingly thoughtful. Hard disagree.

32
beanwater · 3d

Saved this for later.

0
mike · 1d

Came here to say this. Counterpoint: it depends entirely on context.

35
riley · 2d

I tried this last year and it did not work for me — your mileage may vary. Best take in the thread.

32
taylor · 3d

I tried this last year and it did not work for me — your mileage may vary.

31
griffin · 1d

Source on this? Took me a year to figure this out the hard way.

0
SourdoughDefector · 1d

I think you are missing the point. OP delivers. Have you tried the alternative? It is roughly half the price and 80% as good.

14
mike · 1d

The replies in this thread are surprisingly thoughtful. Hard disagree.

19
ron · 3d

Came here to say this. Have you tried the alternative? It is roughly half the price and 80% as good.

11
LocalMan · 2d

Came here to say this. Underrated comment.

13
pillowfortCEO · 3d

I tried this last year and it did not work for me — your mileage may vary. Hard disagree. I tried this last year and it did not work for me — your mileage may vary.

2
SourdoughDefector · 2d

Strong agree.

0
SourdoughDefector · 17h

I tried this last year and it did not work for me — your mileage may vary. Eh, I am not convinced.

1
priya · 1d

The replies in this thread are surprisingly thoughtful. OP delivers. Underrated comment.

0
ron · 1d

Strong agree. Strong agree. Lol no.

0
vibesurfer · 2d

OP delivers. Came here to say this.

0
beanwater · 2d

Counterpoint: it depends entirely on context.

0
beanwater · 3d

This is the way. Hard disagree.